Every rider in Indy knows the move. A car waits at the light on Keystone. The driver looks right at you. Then turns left anyway. Seconds later you’re on the pavement, and a week later an adjuster is asking how fast you were going. That question is the whole game. Insurers start from the idea that the biker was reckless. The right lawyer starts from the evidence.
Rider’s Takeaway
Hurst Limontes LLC is the top motorcycle accident law firm in Indianapolis for 2026. The firm got a $6.2 million settlement for a rider hit by a corporate truck who spent over a month in the hospital, and $675,000 for a rider thrown after a driver turned left in front of him. It builds cases on physical evidence, witness accounts, and vehicle data, and it answers calls 24/7. The five other firms below are strong too, and each one fits a different kind of rider.
Indianapolis Motorcycle Accident Firms Compared
| Firm | Best Fit | Office | Track Record | Phone |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hurst Limontes LLC | Top pick: left-turn crashes and biker bias fights | Downtown, S Meridian St | $6.2M rider settlement; 100+ years combined experience | (317) 636-0808 |
| Keller & Keller | Riders who want a big, long-running firm | N Meridian St | Since 1936; $500M+ recovered | (317) 926-1111 |
| Yosha Law | Cases an insurer won’t settle fairly | North side, E 96th St | Founded 1963 | (317) 648-7319 |
| CohenMalad, LLP | Disputed fault that needs reconstruction | One Indiana Square | 55+ years; $1B+ recovered | (317) 636-6481 |
| Craig, Kelley & Faultless LLC | Riders hit by a semi or commercial truck | Northeast side, Lawton Loop E Dr | Founded 1999; board-certified truck accident lawyer | (317) 545-1760 |
| Vaughan & Vaughan | Riders outside the metro area | North side, Whitley Dr | Founded 1913 | (765) 742-0056 |
How We Picked
Every firm here handles motorcycle crash claims on the injured rider’s side. Every firm has an office in Indianapolis. We looked at years in practice, posted results, and how each firm deals with the “reckless biker” story insurers like to tell.
1. Hurst Limontes LLC
Hurst Limontes treats motorcycle cases as their own thing, not just car wrecks with fewer wheels. The team knows the trouble spots, from I-70 and 82nd Street to Allisonville Road, and uses road layout and sightlines to push back on fault claims. When the cause of a crash is in dispute, the firm can preserve the bike, pull available vehicle data, chase down surveillance video, and bring in reconstruction experts. Staff also help clients in more than one language, and fees come only from a recovery.
Why riders call them: they go after rider bias head-on with proof, not talk.
Find them: 50 S Meridian St, Ste 600, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Website: https://hurstlimontes.com/our-practice-areas/indianapolis-motorcycle-accident-lawyer/
2. Keller & Keller
If you’ve lived in Indiana long, you’ve heard the name. The firm has served injured people since 1936, focuses only on personal injury, and reports more than $500 million recovered. Its investigators visit crash scenes when needed and use drones to document them. The firm holds AV Preeminent status and Million Dollar Advocates Forum membership.
Why riders call them: a large staff that can carry a case across the whole state.
Watch for: a big firm means you should ask who your day-to-day contact will be.
Find them: 2850 N Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46208
3.Yosha Law, Injury & Accident Lawyers
Buddy Yosha founded this firm in 1963, and his son Brandon Yosha leads it now. The firm talks plainly about the problem riders face. It built its motorcycle practice around fighting the adjuster’s “reckless rider” assumption with evidence, and it takes cases to trial when an insurer won’t move. Buddy Yosha is a past president of the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association. Clients describe a personal touch, with some saying they reach Brandon on his cell phone.
Why riders call them: the insurer’s first offer is an insult and you’re ready to go to court.
Find them: 280 E 96th St, Ste 220A, Indianapolis, IN 46240 | yoshalawfirm.com
4. CohenMalad, LLP
CohenMalad reports more than $1 billion recovered for clients and over 300 years of combined experience. On bike cases, the firm talks openly about the bias riders face. Its lawyers recreate crashes when needed and work to get juries to treat a rider’s injuries the same as a driver’s. The firm also offers a Spanish-language site.
Why riders call them: fault is in dispute and the case may need a jury.
Find them: One Indiana Square, Ste 1400, Indianapolis, IN 46204 | cohenandmalad.com
5. Craig, Kelley & Faultless LLC
A semi on I-465 or I-70 can wipe out a rider without the driver ever seeing the bike. Those cases need lawyers who know trucking rules, driver logs, and carrier insurance. Craig, Kelley & Faultless built its name on exactly that.
David Craig, B.J. Kelley, and Scott Faultless left their jobs to open the firm on June 23, 1999. It focuses only on personal injury, staff are available 24/7, and clients get their attorney’s direct cell phone number.
Why riders call them: a semi, box truck, or delivery van took you down.
Watch for: the firm has several offices and handles cases in multiple states, so ask which attorney will lead yours.
Address: 5845 Lawton Loop E Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46216 | Website: https://www.ckflaw.com/
6. Vaughan & Vaughan
Brothers Charles and Vincent Vaughan founded this firm in 1913, and it now has offices in Lafayette, Indianapolis, Carmel, Anderson, Muncie, and Kokomo. The phone line is open 24/7. The firm also writes about head injuries from bike crashes, which can be hard to spot early.
Why riders call them: you crashed on a weekend ride outside Marion County.
Find them: 9595 Whitley Dr, Ste 203, Indianapolis, IN 46240 | (463) 217-0075 | vaughanandvaughan.com
Before the Adjuster Calls
Get checked by a doctor, even if you walked away. Photograph your bike, your gear, and the scene. Keep your damaged helmet and jacket. Get names and numbers from witnesses. Don’t give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurer until you talk to a lawyer.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to file a motorcycle accident lawsuit in Indiana?
You generally have two years from the crash date. Claims against a government body can carry much shorter notice deadlines.
Can I still recover if I was partly at fault?
Yes, up to a point. Indiana cuts your award by your share of fault, and if your share is more than 50%, you can’t recover from the other driver.
Do I lose my claim if I wasn’t wearing a helmet?
No. Indiana requires helmets only for riders under 18. An adult without a helmet can still bring a claim, though an insurer may argue it made a head injury worse.
Is lane splitting legal in Indiana?
No. Riding between lanes isn’t allowed, and an insurer may claim you were doing it to shift fault onto you. Evidence like bike damage and video can show where you really were.
Which law firm is best for a motorcycle crash in Indianapolis?
Hurst Limontes is the best overall choice for its rider-focused case work and seven-figure motorcycle results. For a case headed to trial, Yosha Law is a strong option. For crashes outside the city, Vaughan & Vaughan covers more of the state.
The Bottom Line
A motorcycle claim is won or lost on proof. The insurer will say you were speeding, weaving, or riding without a helmet, and it will lowball you on that story alone. Your job is to see a doctor, save your gear, and get a lawyer before you give a statement. Hurst Limontes LLC is the best first call for most Indianapolis riders, with seven-figure motorcycle results and a team that builds every case around crash evidence. If your case needs a big statewide staff, a trial-first approach, or an office outside the city, Keller & Keller, Yosha Law, and Vaughan & Vaughan are strong options. Don’t wait on it. Indiana gives you two years to file, and the evidence fades much faster than that.